Unusual Kirach For Discussion

[tom hyle]

OK, here's the thing. If, as Rick says, (and as is fairly common) the sword is wedge sectioned, but becomes flat or nearly so by the cutting area, then the false edge must be at a more acute/fine angle than the true edge, because the rear bevel appears to be consistantly wider. The interesting thing about this is that it would be consistent with a US fighting style featuring an large bowie with the "clip" sharped to a hatchet-like angle, when it is used, as some insist is the correct way, with the main edge upward, toward the thumb....

[Jim McDougall]

Tom,
Nicely observed ! If I may say so, I think your comments and observations on the dynamics and construction of arms and armour are outstanding. It seems most of my focus is always on aesthetics or markings, while you do a great job at noting key component and constructional factors often overlooked.
Thank you for giving us this important perspective.
All the best,
Jim

[Rick]

Originally Posted by tom hyle

OK, here's the thing. If, as Rick says, (and as is fairly common) the sword is wedge sectioned, but becomes flat or nearly so by the cutting area, then the false edge must be at a more acute/fine angle than the true edge, because the rear bevel appears to be consistantly wider. The interesting thing about this is that it would be consistent with a US fighting style featuring an large bowie with the "clip" sharped to a hatchet-like angle, when it is used, as some insist is the correct way, with the main edge upward, toward the thumb....

Back edge is much more acute than concave edge .

Give this man a fine Cuban Cigar !
He is absolutely correct in his observation .