So, Trying to Etch a Shamshir

[A.alnakkas]

thanks all! plenty of good ideas. Ibrahim, I think it might be dangerous trying to etch in a metal container? Probably if its copper or anything weaker than steel it would be damaged.

I think etching without emmersing is probably my best option but what kind of etchant should I be using? I have access to Ferric acid but never used it before. The blade shows some faint patterns but I cant be sure what it is, thats why I want to etch.

[Ibrahiim al Balooshi]

Originally Posted by A.alnakkas

thanks all! plenty of good ideas. Ibrahim, I think it might be dangerous trying to etch in a metal container? Probably if its copper or anything weaker than steel it would be damaged.

I think etching without emmersing is probably my best option but what kind of etchant should I be using? I have access to Ferric acid but never used it before. The blade shows some faint patterns but I cant be sure what it is, thats why I want to etch.

Purpose built etching tray. I use one for immersing swords in coke or vinegar...Hot vinegar is as agresive an etchant I have used... I never tried the ferric treatment...Using a tray saves a fortune in materials as it is only 2 inch deep and ideal for the job... and avoids the gymnastics required for other methods like painting it on which as you know does have its issues in this heat ! I repeat that I'm only talking about the soft option coke and vinegar (which you still have to be careful with as it can be a bit tricky if used hot... I use it cold) agreed no need for power tools at all. Did anyone ever use lemon salt?
Ibrahiim al Balooshi.