Federalist sword

Jeff D · 27th December 2010, 05:44 PM

Hi Glen and Mark,

Is it Post #13 that you prove how out of date the 1992 Bazelon article is?
Unfortunately I am a two finger typist and do not have time to type the article, and I have no way of getting the article to you. I will quote Bazelon's acknowledge of these concerns using the same sources as you. His conclusion is that Rose and Prahl are not the sources for these brass hilts but builds a pretty convincing argument for a cottage industry in the Philly area as the source. I will have to leave it to you to find the article and see how he comes to a that conclusion as that is what the entire article is about.
If it is something else in Glens posts that I have missed that show how "out of date" the article is please let me know as I will see if it is addressed.

'...These factors lead to the conclusion that the brass hilts were made by another party working in cooperation with Rose and Prahl'

The reason I bring this up again is that the Bazelon article is the most up to date and thorough discussion on these strange brass hilted swords (that I am aware of). I will happily discard it when some thing better comes along. It also is helping me find an answer to my mystery saber which I won't post here so as not to distract the thread. I think it is the best information on your saber.
Now how about it, lets see those markings. This may the key to proving or disproving the source of these sabers.

All the Best
Jeff

P.S. If you are still unconvinced, I will happily save it from your sea dog collection and place it with my horsey set

27th December 2010, 05:44 PM	#26
Jeff D Member Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: B.C. Canada Posts: 473	Hi Glen and Mark, Is it Post #13 that you prove how out of date the 1992 Bazelon article is? Unfortunately I am a two finger typist and do not have time to type the article, and I have no way of getting the article to you. I will quote Bazelon's acknowledge of these concerns using the same sources as you. His conclusion is that Rose and Prahl are not the sources for these brass hilts but builds a pretty convincing argument for a cottage industry in the Philly area as the source. I will have to leave it to you to find the article and see how he comes to a that conclusion as that is what the entire article is about. If it is something else in Glens posts that I have missed that show how "out of date" the article is please let me know as I will see if it is addressed. '...These factors lead to the conclusion that the brass hilts were made by another party working in cooperation with Rose and Prahl' The reason I bring this up again is that the Bazelon article is the most up to date and thorough discussion on these strange brass hilted swords (that I am aware of). I will happily discard it when some thing better comes along. It also is helping me find an answer to my mystery saber which I won't post here so as not to distract the thread. I think it is the best information on your saber. Now how about it, lets see those markings. This may the key to proving or disproving the source of these sabers. All the Best Jeff P.S. If you are still unconvinced, I will happily save it from your sea dog collection and place it with my horsey set