New member with a sword for review

[Angus1783]

Thank you all for taking the time and for posting your thoughts
Here are a few more photos

[Roland_M]

Originally Posted by Angus1783

Here are a few more photos

Hi Angus,

in my honest opinion, the blade is no modern fake, it is at least from the period of around WW I.
I can see some pitting, which is not too easy to fake. The quality of the forging work seems pretty good, I cannot see any flaws, like open layers or so.

The pattern welded blade is also not a roughly forged blade. If the blade would be polished up to a grit of 2000 oder better 3000 and etched with high detail etchant, you probably will see much more and much finer details than now.

But the siganture, which was translated with "Assad Allah" is not real. Assad Allah was the most famous wootz blacksmith and this definitely no wootz.


Roland

[A.alnakkas]

The signature says "tawakaltu ala Allah" (I rely upon God)

So its not trying to be something that it is not. The blade looks legit with a crude handle and using an old scabbard. Not uncommon to find Ottoman swords with such scabbards.

[Ibrahiim al Balooshi]

Originally Posted by Roland_M

Hi Angus,

in my honest opinion, the blade is no modern fake, it is at least from the period of around WW I.
I can see some pitting, which is not too easy to fake. The quality of the forging work seems pretty good, I cannot see any flaws, like open layers or so.

The pattern welded blade is also not a roughly forged blade. If the blade would be polished up to a grit of 2000 oder better 3000 and etched with high detail etchant, you probably will see much more and much finer details than now.

But the siganture, which was translated with "Assad Allah" is not real. Assad Allah was the most famous wootz blacksmith and this definitely no wootz.


Roland

I think bringing up the blade then waxing the scabbard would be reasonable..There may be parts of this weapon which are joined or mixed ...That can happen but cleaned up this could revive the weapon. Make the best of it and lets see what it looks like after some restoration...Take your time and don't overdo it ... Good luck.