ho can help me with this blade

[A. G. Maisey]

Are we playing the tangguh game AGAIN?

I really do wish that I was good enough to be able to give a supportable tangguh opinion from images on a computer screen.

Semar, tell me, what is the feeling of the pamor texture? Is it fairly coarse and rough, or would you say it has a smooth, almost greasy feel?

Is the blade relatively light, or does it feel relatively heavy?

[semar]

hallo mister Maisey

the blade feel light
en the textur of the pamor it feel smooth, almost greasy feel?



regards semar

[A. G. Maisey]

If the texture is smooth, almost greasy, it is very probably classifiable as Gresik.

Gresik blades look like this one, and Gresik did a lot of copies of other, genuinely prestigious, tangguhs.

I doubt that we can dignify the dhapur with a recognizable name, the pamor is a random m'lumah, thus wos wutah is good enough.

[semar]

thank you mister maisey
I think too that i dont get a propper name of this dapur
yesterday I have a discusie aboud the dapur and some say kabo teki
and when you say thats not posibele you get the aswer thats the freedom of the empu the say to make like this so and of discusi I think

regards semar

[David]

Well I wouldn't call it kebo teki....
...why don't you give it a name semar...

[A. G. Maisey]

An Empu has no freedom, unless he has been directed by his lord to create a new dhapur for a specific purpose, then his freedom is limited to compliance with the wishes of his lord.

A pandai keris, or a tukang does have freedom, because they make blades which do not have the spiritual content of a blade made by an empu.

This blade is not a blade made by an empu.

[semar]

thats what I tel them but the javanees say
you can turn it how you like so better stop whit to look voor a answer

regards semar

[A. G. Maisey]

Yes.

True.

Anybody can believe whatever they wish.

But belief does not reality make.