VIEWS SOUGHT ON MODERN ETHNOGRAPHIC WEAPONS

[spiral]

I was thinking how to word my feelings without misunderstanding on this subject...

But Dave A, has already described my position & view most precisely.

Thank you.

Spiral

Originally Posted by DaveA

I am guided by the artisanship of the finished product. Quality is easy to discern. A well made, hand-made, beautiful and functional edged weapon in a traditional form is worthy of consideration by the collector.

A second consideration is who it is that does the making. It is vastly preferable for me to see a style and expert craftsmanship handed down over generations in a setting that is traditional for the item in question. To me, the linkage of the artifact to the history -- the story -- is very important.

If the item comes from a period of special historical significance, that is a third consideration that makes me sit up and pay attention!

Work of Art + Story + History.

My two cents!

Best,

David