Hi Sjors, I guess beauty is in the eye of the Beholder.
The example I have shown is rarely seen nowadays .
Your example I have no idea about; but (using your criteria) they are keris IMO (some are better than others), junky or not .
The dress here is Gabilan (IMO) in both circumstances; a recognised Maduran form .
Being such it is a part of keris history and culture .
Also, who is to say these were not sometimes owned by poorer local people who still wanted a keris ?