I understand. Regretfully, I am an "ordinary visitor" and we cannot put images of both hilts side by side to compare their decorations. 
 
I looked at the images of the scabbard cover of the discussion object: the material seems to be a tarpaulin or some other impregnated fabric  which is incompatible with old Caucasian origin. Also, it  is perfectly intact, without any signs of age-related wear and tear.  I have to conclude that it is a modern creation. Would you agree?
		 
		
		
		
		
		
		
		
	 |