| 
				 Micro-ethnic differences in weapons 
 
			
			We usually discuss differences in weapons belonging to pretty large  countries/principalities. Usually, these weapons are very different:  North Indian Tulwar vs. South Indian Khanda, Turkish Kilij or Pala vs. Persian Shamshir etc.
 But I would like to bring an example of the same weapon coming from 2 adjacent and pretty small principalities of the same country: Georgia.
 
 First is the map of historical 15th century Georgia. Look at the coastal end: Samegrelo ( Megrelia) and Guria. Both are populated by people speaking the same language and belonging to the same religion ( Christian).
 Both are small: Megrelia  3,800 sq. mi. ( or, to simplify, ~65x65 mi), Guria is tiny at 785 sq.mi. ( ~40x20 mi). Both had kindjals as their main weapons.
 But here the differences start:
 The upper one: Gurian kindlal is massive, wide, and has pretty rounded tip. Its blade is hollow-ground. It is a slashing weapon.
 The lower one, Megrelian is rather small,  narrow,  having a very sharp tip, flat panel at the ricasso and a central rib for strengthening the blade : a stabber.
 
 These features  imply major differences in their actual use.
 
 Their decorations are also very different: Gurian has scabbard  with monstrous iron chapee and square pommel; Megrelian has elegant silver decorations.
 
 These differences were preserved for as long as we know these weapons; these are  firm tradition peculiar to the same people occupying the area size of Long Island.
 
 Can we show other examples of similar micro-ethnic  construction? I would probably not touch Indonesia/Philippine, because  they have not even micro, but nano-differences  belonging not only to different islands, but to different villages.
 
				 Last edited by ariel; 1st January 2020 at 08:36 PM.
 |