Ethnographic Arms & Armour

Ethnographic Arms & Armour (http://www.vikingsword.com/vb/index.php)
-   Ethnographic Weapons (http://www.vikingsword.com/vb/forumdisplay.php?f=2)
-   -   Old talibong (http://www.vikingsword.com/vb/showthread.php?t=26971)

h0ll0wman 16th May 2021 01:51 AM

Old talibong
 
3 Attachment(s)
The second one in my collection. I find it unusual that this talibong is engraved and with a date stamp of "1896".

Sajen 16th May 2021 11:01 AM

It's a nice one and the first I've seen which is dated at the blade. I've seen them dated on the scabbard before.

Regards,
Detlef

Sajen 16th May 2021 11:04 AM

Here you can see a few more: http://www.vikingsword.com/vb/showth...light=talibong

xasterix 16th May 2021 03:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sajen (Post 262622)

Thanks for the redirect Detlef!

Interesting blade; something about the profile reminds me more of a pinuti- Cebu rather than Leyte/Samar. Also the first time I've seen the date engraved on the blade.

jokrho 16th May 2021 03:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by xasterix (Post 262626)
Thanks for the redirect Detlef!

Interesting blade; something about the profile reminds me more of a pinuti- Cebu rather than Leyte/Samar. Also the first time I've seen the date engraved on the blade.

I concur.

The blade profile is that of a Cebuano pinuti. But a lovely specimen of an early one. Congrats!

Battara 16th May 2021 08:10 PM

I agree and it is uncommon to see this type of floral blade engravings (though some even have brass inlay).

h0ll0wman 18th May 2021 02:23 AM

Thank you for the insights! Perhaps this is an old Pinuti from Cebu rather than a talibong from Samar?

Battara 19th May 2021 04:01 AM

Oh I think tailbong came from Cebu too.

h0ll0wman 19th May 2021 10:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Battara (Post 262739)
Oh I think tailbong came from Cebu too.


Thank you for the clarification. To be honest, I am confused about the pinuti and talibong.

xasterix 19th May 2021 10:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Battara (Post 262739)
Oh I think tailbong came from Cebu too.

Hope you don't mind me correcting... "talibong" term actually isn't endemic in Leyte/Samar. The Waray call their battle blades as "sundang" and their utility ones as "bolo." While there's been info in this forum that the rattan-wrapped, thumb-indented, heavy-bellied bolo used to be called "garab," the Filipino Traditional Blades research group is still gathering data on the ground for the actual name of that weapon. They believe that there's a more specific term for that blade that's endemic to the Waray-speaking areas.

This has been the case for Cebuano 'pinuti,' which FTB researched to have different variants with specific blade profiles and other defining features - lawi-lawi, tinamban, lawihan, etc which can be traced back to antique samples as well.

h0ll0wman 19th May 2021 10:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by xasterix (Post 262748)
Hope you don't mind me correcting... "talibong" term actually isn't endemic in Leyte/Samar. The Waray call their battle blades as "sundang" and their utility ones as "bolo." While there's been info in this forum that the rattan-wrapped, thumb-indented, heavy-bellied bolo used to be called "garab," the Filipino Traditional Blades research group is still gathering data on the ground for the actual name of that weapon. They believe that there's a more specific term for that blade that's endemic to the Waray-speaking areas.

This has been the case for Cebuano 'pinuti,' which FTB researched to have different variants with specific blade profiles and other defining features - lawi-lawi, tinamban, lawihan, etc which can be traced back to antique samples as well.

Thank you. This is good information.

JeffS 19th May 2021 12:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by xasterix (Post 262748)
This has been the case for Cebuano 'pinuti,' which FTB researched to have different variants with specific blade profiles and other defining features - lawi-lawi, tinamban, lawihan, etc which can be traced back to antique samples as well.

Cool. Is there a way to view this research?

xasterix 19th May 2021 01:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JeffS (Post 262751)
Cool. Is there a way to view this research?

Yes, it's in the entries of the Filipino Traditional Blades page on Facebook... you'll just have to use the search bar there or browse the past entries, they've discussed and shown samples of pinuti variants extensively.

JeffS 19th May 2021 02:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by xasterix (Post 262756)
Yes, it's in the entries of the Filipino Traditional Blades page on Facebook... you'll just have to use the search bar there or browse the past entries, they've discussed and shown samples of pinuti variants extensively.

Yes, using "pinuti" as a search term brought up dozens of examples. Great resource!
As an aside, I find the similarity between "lawi-lawi" and the Formosa Atayal sword name "lau-lau" or "law-law" interesting. The link between Taiwan and Philippines has been discussed here before but usually in comparison of the open face scabbard design to the Ifaguo hinalung/pinahig. However the acute point, broad belly, and ring ferrule features of many pinuti do match many mountain Formosa blades (though they typically do not have straight spines). I've also seen talibong scabbards that closely match the Atayal scabbard in profile with the flared "fish tail" foot.

jokrho 23rd May 2021 02:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by xasterix (Post 262748)
Hope you don't mind me correcting... "talibong" term actually isn't endemic in Leyte/Samar. The Waray call their battle blades as "sundang" and their utility ones as "bolo." While there's been info in this forum that the rattan-wrapped, thumb-indented, heavy-bellied bolo used to be called "garab," the Filipino Traditional Blades research group is still gathering data on the ground for the actual name of that weapon. They believe that there's a more specific term for that blade that's endemic to the Waray-speaking areas.

This has been the case for Cebuano 'pinuti,' which FTB researched to have different variants with specific blade profiles and other defining features - lawi-lawi, tinamban, lawihan, etc which can be traced back to antique samples as well.

Seconding this. Sundang is to Waray as Pinuti is to Cebuano.

Ian 23rd May 2021 08:00 PM

Jokhro and Xas,

Thanks for clarifying some of these terms again. Trying to peel away the layers of terminology, not to mention mistakes that have been propagated for decades, is impossible from outside the host culture. That's why groups such as FTB, who conduct their research at ground level and post their information freely, are so valuable to collectors here.

Sharing information in this way, some of which has been held closely within the original communities, is the essence of scholarship and learning. It also helps sustain interest in traditional Filipino weapons and their production by local panday.

Jazz 8th June 2021 01:52 AM

Yes, i concure with what xasterix said. A lot of terms that are still being used in this forum are pretty much debunked. A couple pages on Fb are pretty much the go to site on any Moro/Filipino weapons.
To be brutally honest, anything Moro/Filipino in this website was a great intro a long time ago; but nowadays it's more misleading than anything else. As they say in the Philippines, "Sayang!"

Battara 8th June 2021 02:59 AM

I thank you for the updated correction Xasterix.

Maraming Salamat! :)


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 12:44 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Posts are regarded as being copyrighted by their authors and the act of posting material is deemed to be a granting of an irrevocable nonexclusive license for display here.